Cabaret Series
Claybourne Elder: If the Stars Were Mine

Thursday, November 6
6:30pm
Capitol Theater Stage
$173.86
Ticket Price includes hors d’oeuvres and a gourmet 3-course meal from Catering a Fresco.
Age Recommendation
May not be appropriate for young audiences due to content, length or atmosphere.
Broadway’s hunky gay ex-Mormon dad Claybourne Elder, star of “Company,” “Sunday in the Park…” and HBO’s “The Gilded Age,” presents “If the Stars Were Mine,” a hilarious and heartfelt evening that’s part cabaret and part stand-up. Using his favorite music from Sondheim, the Great American Songbook, Whitney Houston and beyond, Elder explores fatherhood, love and what exactly happens when you eat the body of Christ. Come see why critics call him “handsome and intense” (Rex Reed, Observer), “tough and tender” (Joe Dziemianowicz, New York Daily News) and “stupid funny as he is drop-dead buff” (Robert Hofler, The Wrap).
A SAG Award, Grammy, Drama Desk and Lucille Lortel nominee, Elder has built an impressive career spanning Broadway, TV and film. He’s appeared in “The Carrie Diaries,” “FBI” and “Bad Cupid” and voiced a character in the video game “Grand Theft Auto V.” Elder grew up in Utah and studied in France and Russia before moving to New York. A passionate DIY renovator and self-taught chef, he has been featured in Architectural Digest and is the brand spokesperson for Dash. Elder also founded “City of Strangers,” an initiative that has given away over 3,000 Broadway tickets to artists in need.
-
Thu, Nov 6, 2025
6:30 PM

Make Your Own Subscription
Save up to 20% on tickets!
Choose three or more Overture Presents shows to build a Make Your Own Subscription.
Three or four titles: 15% discount
Five or more titles: 20% discount
Please note: Some shows, including Cabaret performances, do not have discounts but do count towards number requirements.
We also offer Broadway at Overture packages.
Dinner Menu
Hors D'oeuvres - Capitol Theater Lobby - 6:30pm
Dinner - Capitol Theater Stage - 7pm
Entreé: Turkey roulade with Marsala brown gravy, orange-cranberry stuffing, smoked sweet potatoes and creamed spinach*
Includes a salad and dessert course
Wine, spirits, soft drinks and beer available for purchase all evening
*menus may change based on availability - thank you!
Photos
Upcoming Cabaret Events
-
2025/26 Season, Cabaret, Music, Overture Presents Claybourne Elder: If the Stars Were Mine
Capitol Theater Stage
Broadway’s hunky gay ex-Mormon dad Claybourne Elder, star of “Company,” “Sunday in the Park…” and HBO’s “The Gilded Age,” presents a hilarious and heartfelt evening that’s part cabaret and part stand-up.
6:30 PM -
2025/26 Season, Cabaret, Music, Overture Presents Kyle Taylor Parker: Juke Joint Jubilee
Capitol Theater Stage
Don’t miss Broadway powerhouse Kyle Taylor Parker in a thrilling evening of soulful vocals and show-stopping storytelling. From his acclaimed turns in “Kinky Boots” and “Smokey Joe’s Café” to his celebrated solo albums, KTP is ready to dazzle and delight in this intimate cabaret concert.
6:30 PM -
2025/26 Season, Cabaret, Music, Overture Presents Patti Murin: Once Upon a Stage
Capitol Theater Stage
Broadway star Patti Murin invites you on a journey through the music that has shaped her illustrious career. Murin brings her signature warmth, themes of love, resilience and the power of dreams—weaving in heartfelt reflections on motherhood and its impact on her life and artistry.
6:30 PM